Life-history variation and comparative phylogeography of darters (Pisces: Percidae) from the north American central highlands

Abstract

Phylogeography seeks to evaluate the relationship between genetic variation and geographic distribution of a species to examine the influence of historical events on divergence. Congruent phylogeographic patterns in codistributed species indicate historical association of the taxa being compared, and the uniform action of biogeographic events in shaping genetic variation. We sought to evaluate the congruence of patterns of genetic variation of five closely related fish species across a well-defined biogeographic boundary. We gathered allozymic and mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) sequence data for five species of darters (Percidae: Etheostomatini) from populations distributed among biogeographic regions in the Ozark and Ouachita highlands of the south-central United States. Comparisons among species revealed noncongruence in the magnitude of genetic divergence in both allozymes and mtDNA sequences. We hypothesized that noncongruence resulted, in part, from differences in life histories of the species in our comparison. To address this hypothesis, we evaluated the association between gene flow (measured by N(e)m) and variation in body size and fecundity variables because they have been shown to influence gene flow in fishes. Correlation analysis revealed an association between gene flow and fecundity (r = 0.88), but not with body size (r = 0.36) or reproductive investment per individual (r = -0.23). The result was similar when independent contrasts of the original variables were used in correlation analyses. Phylogeographic analysis of mtDNA sequence data indicated the importance of history, evident in gene trees of Percina nasuta and Percina phoxocephala. Divergence rates between these two taxa may differ because of historically persistent differences in population sizes, reflected in present-day abundance and fecundity differences. Conversely, Percina caprodes showed little evidence of divergence in mtDNA sequences and yielded the highest mean N(e)m values from allozyme data. Comparisons among closely related, codistributed taxa may help discriminate among the possibilities for noncongruence in biogeographic studies by allowing evaluation of the influence of life history on patterns of gene flow.