The Time-Dependent Lead-Lag Relationship Between WTI and Brent Crude Oil Spot Markets

Abstract

Based on daily returns, we comprehensively characterize the lead-lag relationship between Brent and WTI crude oil spot markets from 1987 to 2017 with the non-parametric symmetric thermal optimal path (TOPS) method. The empirical results indicate that WTI spot price leads Brent spot price slightly, which provides support to the price leadership of WTI over Brent. However, the lead-lag relationship is volatile and sensitive to extreme events like geopolitical conflict and policy shift. Due to the concerns about future oil supply triggered by the two Gulf wars, both WTI and Brent experienced extreme uncertainty and co-moved closely during wartime. Notably, the TOPS method captures the structural break in the WTI-Brent price spread in 2011 which is influenced by the U.S. oil export ban and transportation bottleneck. After the lift of the ban, the two benchmark prices have reconnected. The lead-lag signals basically coincide with major influential changes in the oil markets, which suggests that the TOPS method provides a viable approach to reflecting the impact of extreme events on the crude oil prices motion.